I am not a photographer (though very interested in photography!) but I do fairly basic digital retouching for wedding customers. I have received a few discs of photos from the same photographer a few times now with the same problem.
About a quarter from the left border of a landscape image, a vertical, single-pixel greenish line run through. I've zoomed in and can see a small (maybe 2x2 pixel) white spot about 5 pixels from the top of the image, and the green line runs vertically down from there, right to the bottom of the image. This littel white spot looks like there's a "hole" in the image, which is "leaking" the green line.
Can this learned forum please advise me as to why this keeps happening?
I have raised this previously with the photographer and he told me last time it was down to a corrupted media card. That sounded wrong to me, as an IT support pro - if the media card was corrupt, we would be having other issues. (That's not to say he was being dishonest - he's not an IT person.) He told me he ditched the faulty card, but here we are again. I suspect he's mis-diagnosing the problem, and that ditching this data card too will not fix the issue.
Could his explanation be right? I suspect it's a problem with his camera and that he's giving me excuses to fob off having to spend money on it. I'd be very grateful for advice, as I don't want to dismiss him if I'm wrong. He tells me he took many more photos after the ones he took for me, and none of them have this issue, so he reckons it's ot the camera. Then again he never noticed this the first time, nor this time, until I raised it with him.
Here's Johnny <r...@tattat.net> wrote: > I am not a photographer (though very interested in photography!) but I do > fairly basic digital retouching for wedding customers. I have received a few > discs of photos from the same photographer a few times now with the same > problem.
> About a quarter from the left border of a landscape image, a vertical, > single-pixel greenish line run through. I've zoomed in and can see a small > (maybe 2x2 pixel) white spot about 5 pixels from the top of the image, and > the green line runs vertically down from there, right to the bottom of the > image. This littel white spot looks like there's a "hole" in the image, > which is "leaking" the green line.
> Can this learned forum please advise me as to why this keeps happening?
> I have raised this previously with the photographer and he told me last time > it was down to a corrupted media card. That sounded wrong to me, as an IT > support pro - if the media card was corrupt, we would be having other > issues. (That's not to say he was being dishonest - he's not an IT person.) > He told me he ditched the faulty card, but here we are again. I suspect he's > mis-diagnosing the problem, and that ditching this data card too will not > fix the issue.
> Could his explanation be right? I suspect it's a problem with his camera and > that he's giving me excuses to fob off having to spend money on it. I'd be > very grateful for advice, as I don't want to dismiss him if I'm wrong. He > tells me he took many more photos after the ones he took for me, and none of > them have this issue, so he reckons it's ot the camera. Then again he never > noticed this the first time, nor this time, until I raised it with him.
Sounds like a sensor issue to me. If that line is on the same place in each picture, the chance that this is a memory card issue is practically zero.
Johan W. Elzenga wrote: > Here's Johnny <r...@tattat.net> wrote:
>> I am not a photographer (though very interested in photography!) but >> I do fairly basic digital retouching for wedding customers. I have >> received a few discs of photos from the same photographer a few >> times now with the same problem.
>> About a quarter from the left border of a landscape image, a >> vertical, single-pixel greenish line run through. I've zoomed in and >> can see a small (maybe 2x2 pixel) white spot about 5 pixels from the >> top of the image, and the green line runs vertically down from >> there, right to the bottom of the image. This littel white spot >> looks like there's a "hole" in the image, which is "leaking" the >> green line.
>> Can this learned forum please advise me as to why this keeps >> happening?
>> I have raised this previously with the photographer and he told me >> last time it was down to a corrupted media card. That sounded wrong >> to me, as an IT support pro - if the media card was corrupt, we >> would be having other issues. (That's not to say he was being >> dishonest - he's not an IT person.) He told me he ditched the faulty >> card, but here we are again. I suspect he's mis-diagnosing the >> problem, and that ditching this data card too will not fix the issue.
>> Could his explanation be right? I suspect it's a problem with his >> camera and that he's giving me excuses to fob off having to spend >> money on it. I'd be very grateful for advice, as I don't want to >> dismiss him if I'm wrong. He tells me he took many more photos after >> the ones he took for me, and none of them have this issue, so he >> reckons it's ot the camera. Then again he never noticed this the >> first time, nor this time, until I raised it with him.
> Sounds like a sensor issue to me. If that line is on the same place in > each picture, the chance that this is a memory card issue is > practically zero.
Thanks mate. It turns out it's a hot sensor pixel, and www.pixelfixer.org has a tool for me to fix it - I really hope it can be used for batch processing, because 600 photos by hand is not a fun prospect!
|
