A bit overplayed, I thought. Yes, Kate might have refused to marry the
rich American bastard industrialist, although most young women of that
class would understand that once they married and produced an heir,
discrete affairs were tolerated and widely practiced.
But I don't believe her visiting the 3rd class deck or getting talked
out of suicide by a 3rd class passenger. I don't believe a young woman
in her position having sex in a car in the hold of a ship with a man she
met about 24 hours before.
I don't believe they could have gotten into the kitches, holds, or
engineering spaces of the ship, or evaded capture if they did. I
definitely don't believe Bastard Industrialist inviting Leonardo to dine
in 1st class. I don't believe the ship's Master at Arms would have
turned the job of guarding Leo over to Bastard's goon. I'm having
trouble remembering how many times Kate or Leo or Bastard turned down a
nice safe seat in a lifeboat in order to rescue or chase one of the
others, and I don't believe it any of the times it was shown.
I also don't believe Bastard would have continued to want to marry Kate
even after Kate made it completely clear that she hated the whole idea.
It wouldn't have been that hard for a rich, reasonably handsome man to
find an arm decoration who actually wanted the job.
-- Patrick