I read Still Life with Woodpecker and absolutely loved it. However I
can't seem to get into Jitterbug Perfume. Does anyone have any feelings
on what's different with these two books. Does anyone feel the same way I
do, or the opposite?
-Brian Hill
Hi Brian,
I felt like Still Life was the end of one TR phase and Jitterbug was the
beginning of a new one. You might want to read "backwards" with Cowgirls
and ARA if you liked Still Life. It's all good, though.
Dale
I had the feeling you described when I read HAIFP. It was a bumpy ride for
me and difficult to adjust to the new style. (2nd person.)
Jitterbug is my favorite. I guess you have to be able to read about Alobar
and Kudra as if they are a fairy tale at first. Have you tried that?
Love,
Slugo
--
"I can't even be bothered
Energy breaks me down." -The Charlatans
Gregg
: Gregg
Hi.
Have gotten a good bit of response from my earlier post. Will give JP
another shot before canning it ;)
brian
> At 11:36 AM 4/21/96, Charles Hill wrote:
> >Hi. I'm a newbie to Tom Robbins, as well as a newbie to this newsgroup,
> >and I was wondering if I could get some input on a question.
> >
> >I read Still Life with Woodpecker and absolutely loved it. However I
> >can't seem to get into Jitterbug Perfume. Does anyone have any feelings
> >on what's different with these two books. Does anyone feel the same way I
> >do, or the opposite?
> >
> >-Brian Hill
>
i think JP needs to be approached as an epic fairy tale (is there such a
thing?) or a fantasy...
it's unlike any of his other books, yet it's purely TR.
Ken
_____________________________________________________________
Ken Booker
University of Texas at Austin
e-mail: kbo...@mail.utexas.edu
"It's the end of the world as we know it
And I feel fine"
- R.E.M.
My fav Robbins novel is Jitterbug, so I am disappointed that you couldn't get into it... I personally felt that Woodpecker was one of his weakest (Weak in the sense that Stallone is weaker then Swarzenagger (sp?)... Oh well, chacun son gout, I guess... Well, enjoy the rest of Tom's bibliography, I would suggest reading Skinny Legs next!
My sentiments entirely, Daniel. My two fav books are Skinny Legs and
Jitterbug. The characters are all on journeys with no particular destination
and they pick up a few of Life's lessons on the way. I've read Woodpecker
three or four times now and every time I get a melancholy feeling out it.
Maybe it's just me :)
Cowgirls' The Chink and Dr Robbins, Woodpecker's Bernard Mickey Wrangle and
Frog Pajamas' Larry Diamond sometimes ,when I'm feeling cynical, come across
as all-knowing wiseguys (Wiggs Dannyboy in Jitterbug isn't mentioned in this
list as his role is more of a subplot). This means that one can put across a
complex viewpoint or philosophy quickly but goes against my concept of
"no-one has a monopoly on wisdom".
The way I see TR's collection is as two loose trilogies. Another Roadside
Attraction, Jitterbug Perfume and Skinny Legs and All as one trilogy and
Even Cowgirls Get The Blues, Still Life With Woodpecker and Half Asleep In
Frog Pajamas as the other.
So back to your question, Brian. Perhaps your preference is for a
protagonist with a good idea on Life, the Universe and Everything and how
their philosophy bounces off the other characters. In that case I would
highly recommend you reading Cowgirls next.
Where there's a Will there's a way