That may be. But he is not insane in the way that most people
ignorantly think. He did not teach the things most commonly
attributed to him--e.g. fatalism, hard determinism, the metaphysical
impossibility of free will, the non-existence or illusory nature of
human choice, an Ockhamistic definition of "good", etc. He
explicitly denied all those things and taught against them.
It is fine to argue, of course, that what he did teach logically
entails or inevitably leads to any or all of those positions. But
that's different from saying that he consciously taught such things
and/or knew where his teaching led and deliberately lied and claimed
he didn't. It's the difference between claiming that keeping pot
illegal leads to suffering by the ill, murder and theft by
distributors and users, and lower tax revenue, and claiming that
people who want to keep pot illegal desire those outcomes and pursue
their policy with those goals.
Calvin would have said that the Dark Knight shooter chose to do what
he did freely, with no external coercion. Calvin would have said the
shooter behaved responsibly and culpably. He would have said the man
had no excuse for his behavior, least of all the excuse of saying
that God foreordained the action so he had no choice. He also would
have said that these actions are not uncoverable by Christ's atoning
sacrifice. They do not place the shooter beyond the possibility of
redemption. He has not forfeited his access to the grace of God and
love of God proffered in Christ. And Calvin would say that this is
good news. It is good news for all of us deliberate, culpable,
inexcusable sinners.
And with all that, I agree. It is good news for me. And I have a
responsibility to that good news to think of this young man without
hatred, malice, or condemnation. Though I can and should think of
his actions with horror (never forgetting that my own sins, while
not so public or humanly consequential, are also things of horror),
I must think of the man himself with love and with a hope for his
forgiveness and redemption.
--
Opus the Insane Penguin
The most insane penguin in all of Usenet