[comp.lang.c++ snipped - followups set to comp.lang.c]
anurag said:
> hey can anyone help me in writing a code in c (function) that prints > all permutations of a string.please help
Consider how you would do this by hand. For example, let's look at the string "ABCD". We can think of the permutations of this string as being divided into four sets (because the string is four characters long):
1) All the strings starting with A and continuing with some permutation of BCD 2) All the strings starting with B and continuing with some permutation of CDA 3) All the strings starting with C and continuing with some permutation of DAB 4) All the strings starting with D and continuing with some permutation of ABC
As you might imagine, you can get at these sets simply by moving the string around a little.
Let's look at just one of these sets (because the others are dealt with in the same way, obviously): strings starting with A and continuing with some permutation of BCD.
We are now faced with the problem of finding all the strings containing BCD (which we can simply append to A to get the full permutation).
We can think of the permutations of this string as being divided into three sets (because the string is three characters long):
1) All the strings starting with B and continuing with some permutation of CD 2) All the strings starting with C and continuing with some permutation of DB 3) All the strings starting with D and continuing with some permutation of BC
As you might imagine, you can get at these sets simply by moving the string around a little.
Let's look at just one of these sets (because the others are dealt with in the same way, obviously): strings starting with (A and then) B and continuing with some permutation of CD.
We are now faced with the problem of finding all the strings containing CD (which we can simply append to AB to get the full permutation).
We can think of the permutations of this string as being divided into two sets (because the string is two characters long):
1) All the strings starting with C and continuing with some permutation of D 2) All the strings starting with D and continuing with some permutation of C
As you might imagine, you can get at these sets simply by moving the string around a little.
Let's look at just one of these sets (because the others are dealt with in the same way, obviously): strings starting with (A and then B and then) C, and continuing with some permutation of D.
We are now faced with the problem of finding all the strings containing D (which we can simply append to ABC to get the full permutation).
We can think of the permutations of this string as being divided into one set (because the string is one character long):
1) All the string starting with D - which is obvious, of course.
The canonical way to do this is via recursion, passing in the string, together with the number of items yet to be permuted. If that number is 0, simply display the string. Otherwise, loop around the leftmost not-yet-handled character and, within the loop, recurse with n-1.
Now take a crack at it yourself, and let us know how you get on.
-- Richard Heathfield "Usenet is a strange place" - dmr 29/7/1999 http://www.cpax.org.uk email: rjh at above domain (but drop the www, obviously)
anurag wrote: > hey can anyone help me in writing a code in c (function) that prints > all permutations of a string.please help
IIRC, this favour has been requested a number of times in recent weeks. I wonder why the sudden interest in permuting strings using C functions.
In any case, to give a concrete example of what R.H. discusses elsethread, here's an attempt I made a few weeks ago, when the question first came up. Take it as you will.
For the regulars: yes I know that answering a homework question is frowned apon, and even worse is answering an algorithm question, but this one piqued my interest. So, for my one freebie a year, I post this code ;-)
anurag wrote: > hey can anyone help me in writing a code in c (function) that prints > all permutations of a string.please help
Yes. First learn that C++ and C are different languages, so posting to comp.lang.c++ is entirely inappropriate if you want a C solution.
Having excluded comp.lang.c++ you should first try to write your algorithm. comp.lang.c does not generally help with algorithms, comp.programming and alt.comp.lang.c-c++ might, check the groups out to see. comp.lang.c discusses the C language and helps people with C problems.
Then, post specific questions rather than just asking someone to help you writing it. A lot of us could write the function in less time that it would take to explain it to you, but this would not help you to learn.
If you don't know where to start, then I suggest you start off by trying to write all the permutations of a short string by hand rather than trying to write a program to do it. Then you can analyse how you did it and try to formalise that in to an algorithm.
I've excluded comp.lang.c++ from the follow-ups. When you have decided whether you have a problem with the C language or with writing the algorithm please cut the posting down to only the most appropriate group. -- Flash Gordon, living in interesting times. Web site - http://home.flash-gordon.me.uk/ comp.lang.c posting guidelines and intro: http://clc-wiki.net/wiki/Intro_to_clc
In article <1153418276.122549.15...@m79g2000cwm.googlegroups.com>, anurag <anurag1...@gmail.com> writes
>hey can anyone help me in writing a code in c (function) that prints >all permutations of a string.please help
That looks like homework. In addition it is under specified. Are the characters in the string all unique or are repeats allowed? If they are all unique it is very easy :)
Francis Glassborow <fran...@robinton.demon.co.uk> writes: > In article <1153418276.122549.15...@m79g2000cwm.googlegroups.com>, > anurag <anurag1...@gmail.com> writes >>hey can anyone help me in writing a code in c (function) that prints >>all permutations of a string.please help
> That looks like homework. In addition it is under specified. Are the > characters in the string all unique or are repeats allowed? If they > are all unique it is very easy :)
> anurag wrote: >> hey can anyone help me in writing a code in c (function) that prints >> all permutations of a string.please help
> Knuth, Volume 4 fascicle 2.
As I recall, Knuth does not discuss or mention arithmetic coding of permutations (using the factorial number system), so is not a complete reference.
-- A: Because it messes up the order in which people normally read text. Q: Why is it such a bad thing? A: Top-posting. Q: What is the most annoying thing on usenet and in e-mail?
> * Noah Roberts: >> anurag wrote: >>> hey can anyone help me in writing a code in c (function) that prints >>> all permutations of a string.please help >> Knuth, Volume 4 fascicle 2.
> As I recall, Knuth does not discuss or mention arithmetic coding of > permutations (using the factorial number system), so is not a complete > reference.
Is that necessary to answer the OP's question? I doubt it. -- "doe not call up Any that you can not put downe." --H. P. Lovecraft
Alf P. Steinbach wrote: > * Noah Roberts: > > anurag wrote: > >> hey can anyone help me in writing a code in c (function) that prints > >> all permutations of a string.please help
> > Knuth, Volume 4 fascicle 2.
> As I recall, Knuth does not discuss or mention arithmetic coding of > permutations (using the factorial number system), so is not a complete > reference.
Yeah, I don't know what's actually in it. I have it but haven't gotten the time to read it yet. Knuth takes me an extraordinary amount of time to read. But it's title is "Generating all permutations and combinations" so I figured it would be appropriate. Guy might learn something instead of having his homework done for him.
Alf P. Steinbach wrote: > * Noah Roberts: >> anurag wrote: >>> hey can anyone help me in writing a code in c (function) that prints >>> all permutations of a string.please help
>> Knuth, Volume 4 fascicle 2.
> As I recall, Knuth does not discuss or mention arithmetic coding of > permutations (using the factorial number system), so is not a complete > reference.
When you refer to arithmetic coding of permutations using the factorial number system, are you talking about an algorithm that assigns a unique index number to each permutation and can return any individual permutation given its index number?
/* calculate factorial of given number */ ull fact(ull a) { ull result = 1; while(a) result *= a--; return result;
}
/* generates a permutation of str and stores it in 'rs' the permutation generated is index number 'no' of 'np' total permutations (np == fact(strlen(str)) */ void get_perm(char *rs, const char *str, ull no, ull np) { size_t len = strlen(str); ull nm = no; ull lt; char *p; char temp; strcpy(rs, str);
Lew Pitcher wrote: > For the regulars: yes I know that answering a homework question is > frowned apon, and even worse is answering an algorithm question, but > this one piqued my interest. So, for my one freebie a year, I post this > code ;-)
The code gives the same amount of permutations for following two cases, is it correct?
Ben Pfaff wrote: > "Alf P. Steinbach" <al...@start.no> writes:
> > * Noah Roberts: > >> anurag wrote: > >>> hey can anyone help me in writing a code in c (function) that prints > >>> all permutations of a string.please help > >> Knuth, Volume 4 fascicle 2.
> > As I recall, Knuth does not discuss or mention arithmetic coding of > > permutations (using the factorial number system), so is not a complete > > reference.
> Is that necessary to answer the OP's question? I doubt it. > -- > "doe not call up Any that you can not put downe." > --H. P. Lovecraft
Why? Up to now, the code given by you C experts are all wrong. Are you all line-shooters?
"lovecreatesbeauty" <lovecreatesbea...@gmail.com> writes: > Why? Up to now, the code given by you C experts are all wrong. Are you > all line-shooters?
There's a test program at http://cvs.savannah.gnu.org/viewcvs/*checkout*/pspp/tests/libpspp/ll-... -- int main(void){char p[]="ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZabcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz.\ \n",*q="kl BIcNBFr.NKEzjwCIxNJC";int i=sizeof p/2;char *strchr();int putchar(\ );while(*q){i+=strchr(p,*q++)-p;if(i>=(int)sizeof p)i-=sizeof p-1;putchar(p[i]\ );}return 0;}
> anurag wrote: > > hey can anyone help me in writing a code in c (function) that prints > > all permutations of a string.please help
> IIRC, this favour has been requested a number of times in recent weeks. > I wonder why the sudden interest in permuting strings using C > functions.
> In any case, to give a concrete example of what R.H. discusses > elsethread, here's an attempt I made a few weeks ago, when the question > first came up. Take it as you will.
> For the regulars: yes I know that answering a homework question is > frowned apon, and even worse is answering an algorithm question, but > this one piqued my interest. So, for my one freebie a year, I post this > code ;-)
Noah Roberts wrote: > anurag wrote: >> hey can anyone help me in writing a code in c (function) that prints >> all permutations of a string.please help
> Knuth, Volume 4 fascicle 2.
Based on their source I assume these are "legal" links to the pre-fascicles: