Melissa
Last word I heard was this book will go to Kelson's birth so will
include the Marluk episode. The third book goes up to the start of
Deryni Rising.
jerry
julianne you and your family are in our prayers
jerry
Melissa
will this will include the Marluk story rewritten or is that in the
third book?
Melissa
Irene
"Shiral" <shir...@hotmail.com> wrote in message
news:1137722195.4...@g47g2000cwa.googlegroups.com...
Irene
"Shiral" <shir...@hotmail.com> wrote in message
news:1137722195.4...@g47g2000cwa.googlegroups.com...
Melissa
"Shiral" <shir...@hotmail.com> wrote in message
news:1137999501.6...@g14g2000cwa.googlegroups.com...
Marion
Oh, Marion, I'm sure he was just an insufferable, -umm, I mean, *adorbale*-
child
>After all, I think the Arilans are supposed to be in it,
> too, aren't they?
Saving the story from all that perfection, I'm sure.... ;)
-Mak
http://www.thirtytwopaws.com/mak
http://www.livejournal.com/users/2ndsoprano
Time is that quality of nature which keeps events from happening all at
once. Lately it doesn't seem to be working.
-- Anonymous
Yes, the Snooty umm....superior, ummmmm... RESPECTABLE Arilan family will
also be in Childe Morgan.
Melissa
jerry
Wrong turn, indeed! He just found his sea-legs!
<grin>
--
Wes Struebing
I pledge allegiance to the Constitution of the United States of America,
and to the republic which it established, one nation from many peoples,
promising liberty and justice for all.
Another one... *sigh* :)
My children asked me if they were gifted. I told them I certainly wouldn't
have paid for them!
Melissa
Swashbucklers are a dime a dozen, and overrated, at that. Pardon me if I
prefer a more reserved, intelligent type... :P
Time is that quality of nature which keeps events from happening all at
Shiral wrote:
> opposed to a priest who behaves as if he sat down on broken glass. =o)
ooooh, ouch, Melissa!
Although I'm inclined to agree.
Otoh, I don't get involved in this debate (surrrre, right!) because my
preference comes from Camber's time period. ;)
***************
blessed be, Julianne
Uh, Jerry - that was playing nice. The Arilan/Alaric discussion can get
pretty heated. Alaric fans are so irrational over Duke Mr. Perfect,
whereas the Arilan fans appreciate a character with complexity...
You're right, though, he did seem like a good kid in Swords. Either
way, I'm looking forward to this next book!
Marion
This book will probably start in the 1090's and cover Morgan's
childhood and adolescence up to approximately 1106 or1107, so Derry
probably won't be in it. But he'll be in the third book of the series.
=o)
Melissa
In some ways I think the third will be more interesting than this
second one. It will undoubtedly set up a lot of the political
situations that will plague Kelson. We should see more of Wencit and
maybe how Coram did his Rhydon assumption. And another war with Meara
if I am not mistaken.
jerry
>Melissa
Anybody can swash a buckle, but only the select few can pull off
sitting on broken glass. I like Arilan because I'm never sure how he's
going to act. Alaric's always going to be insufferably noble and always
right.
Marion
Exactly, Marion. And he is often the one who will voice what everyone else
is thinking, but are too "nice" or afraid to say out loud.
Time is that quality of nature which keeps events from happening all at
My very favourite characters, however, are from the Heirs of Saint Camber
era. These and the Camber books are my preferred read, though I enjoy the
Kelson / Alaric series, too.
> Marion
Maybe because most people are sensible enough to get right back up? =o)
As to saying what everyone else is thinking, okay, I like that aspect
of Arilan. What irritates me about him is his self-appointed
guardianship of "justifiable" use of Deryni powers, and unwilling to
grant that Duncan and Alaric can make their own decisions on that
matter without his needing to be their nanny. Alaric has been at court
for several years, he's an adult. If he had been wildly irresponsible
in the use of his powers all along, he never would have lasted as long
as he did. And Duncan was able to survive in the very Deryni-unfriendly
atmosphere of the church, just as Arilan did. Before he revealed
himself to them as Deryni, Arilan had to let them make their own
decisions about their conduct. But ever since then, he doesn't seem to
have any faith in their judgement.
Melissa
And I see Alaric developing his own huffy attitude about some things Deryni.
If Denis or the Council have any sort of opinion, he assumes it's wrong.
And I think he's being just as unfair in that respect as anyone on the
"other side." Which is another point- Alaric seems to have decided that
there are sides- his and theirs. It should be "ours," as in Deryni in
general. Automatic antagonism doesn't help.
All that aside, as I have said on many other occasions, it's not that I
dislike Alaric. I like him well enough. He's just not my first choice. As
Marion is fond of saying, he's just a little too perfect for my taste.
Time is that quality of nature which keeps events from happening all at
It's Kelson I can't stand! That whiny brat needs a good kick in the ass :-)
Oh, definitely. Reminds me of how badly I wanted to give Anakin a darn good
slap in "Attack of the Clones"!! ::ROFL::
I think Kelson is great most of the time, and has dealt with having to
assume royal responsibility very well on the whole, but he does have those
'adolescent' tendencies - probably because he *is* adolescent during most of
the books. :-)
He also suffers hero-worship of Alaric, which I feel clouds his judgement on
occasion.
I wouldn't have minded an outburst of grief now and then on account of
Rothana in KKB, as he and she truly did get a raw deal thanks to
Conall, but not a three year sulk! I would have thought that Alaric,
Duncan and Dhugal would have ALL given him some frank and bracing "Buck
up camper" talks, rather than tolerate that behavior from Kelson. None
of his closest friends strike me as being willing to endure a lot of
whining from anybody.
Re Hero worship of Alaric... well, that I can understand. Here was
this charismatic friend of his father's who obviously also cared for
Kelson himself deeply. Alaric is just the sort of person a growing boy
WOULD naturally want to emulate. And Jehana's disapproval of Morgan
would only have made Morgan more attractive in Kelson's eyes. There's
also no denying that when Kelson needed him most, Morgan came through
for him. He knows he can rely absolutely on Morgan's loyalty, and on
Duncan's and Dhugal's. But as I said above, Kelson's three closest
friends would have done him a great service if any or all of them had
sat him down and said "Grow up, this mooning about over this woman is
not typical of you. Yes, you got a raw deal, but you're a grown man,
act like one!" And if they hadn't done that for Kelson, Nigel certainly
should have.
Hopefully Araxie won't let Kelson get away with mooning about or
whining.... Presumably, she keeps him busy with all the babies she
produces.
Melissa
And if you think that about Kelson, I shudder to wonder what you must
think about Cinhil, who really needs a good shot upside the head!
***********
blessed be, Julianne
<snipped>
:: round of applause ::
Very well argued, Melissa.
I never said, or meant to suggest, that there wasn't reason for Kelson's
hero-worship of Alaric; he is, after all, a father-figure to Kelson - along
with Nigel, of course. But don't we all find that hero-worship can cloud
our judgement on occasion? Those times we find ourselves asking "what would
(X) do?" can sometimes find us making a silly decision rather than a
sensible one - at least that's been my experience. ;-)
Also, there's a difference between having to behave maturely in a public
sphere and actually being emotionally mature. Personal disappointments are
always more difficult to cope with internally than showing honour in public.
Royal responsibility and how to behave with decorum will have been ingrained
in Kelson from a very early age as part of his training as the future king.
Dealing with his disappointment over the loss of Rothana was perhaps a
trigger to vent the pent up feelings of being robbed of so many things in
his life to date, starting with Brion. There was a lot of bad stuff stored
up there.
There you go... now we've rationalised his behaviour, I don't feel so bad
about Kelson having a strop - though it perhaps shouldn't have lasted as
long as it did.
Too bad there were no psychoanalysts about in the early medieval period. :-D
Melissa
<SNIPPITY>
> Why anyone would ague in favor of either is beyond me
> but to each their own. (I am like Julianne, I think the best
> characters are in the Camber era)
>
Here Here!
They all seemed much more developed during the original cycle of camber
novels.....not so much in the later ones, probably as a function of more
characters sharing screen time sort of speak (no I don't want to see another
casting thread, ACK!)
-Mark
>
> :: round of applause ::
> Very well argued, Melissa.
>
> I never said, or meant to suggest, that there wasn't reason for Kelson's
> hero-worship of Alaric; he is, after all, a father-figure to Kelson - along
> with Nigel, of course. But don't we all find that hero-worship can cloud
> our judgement on occasion? Those times we find ourselves asking "what would
> (X) do?" can sometimes find us making a silly decision rather than a
> sensible one - at least that's been my experience. ;-)
This is true. Except, when has Alaric given Kelson truly bad advice?
There is the matter of the tension between Kelson and Co, and Arilan
and the Camberian Council, but I hold the Council equally responsible
for that. Their attitude toward Morgan and Duncan was to say the
least, not broad-minded. Instead of focusing on "Well, they're Deryni
in high places which is helpful to all our cause, and they're doing the
best they can, and we hear they can HEAL!" Kyri and Vivienne chose
instead to hone in on their being "Half-breeds" and therefor beyond
the pale. I thought the council made another, similar boo-boo in their
attitude toward Jessamy. They treated her with hostility and suspicion
as Lewys ap Norfal's daughter, when a bit of sympathy and understanding
from them toward her might have made an ally of Jessamy, instead.
>
> Also, there's a difference between having to behave maturely in a public
> sphere and actually being emotionally mature. Personal disappointments are
> always more difficult to cope with internally than showing honour in public.
> Royal responsibility and how to behave with decorum will have been ingrained
> in Kelson from a very early age as part of his training as the future king.
>
> Dealing with his disappointment over the loss of Rothana was perhaps a
> trigger to vent the pent up feelings of being robbed of so many things in
> his life to date, starting with Brion. There was a lot of bad stuff stored
> up there.
>
> There you go... now we've rationalised his behaviour, I don't feel so bad
> about Kelson having a strop - though it perhaps shouldn't have lasted as
> long as it did.
>
> Too bad there were no psychoanalysts about in the early medieval period. :-D
Why do I have this image of Kelson lying on the couch, being analyzed
by Sigmund Freud? =o)
Melissa
And in response to jerry's proposition about seeing more about Wencit,
that would be fascinating as well. Baddies generally have such
interesting histories! Childhood trauma, lost love that turned them
bitter forever, etc., etc. Could be fun!
On 24 Jan 2006 03:47:15 -0800, "jerry" <jjm...@bellsouth.net> wrote:Now Now children Play nice. Maybe this book will show us how Morgan got is superior attitude about himself. He seemed like a good kid in Swords against the Marluk so I guess we will have to wait until the next book to see where he made the wrong turn.Wrong turn, indeed! He just found his sea-legs! <grin>
I thought it was rather out of character for Kelson, but then, maybe I
expected too much of him. I liked him quite a lot in DR and thought "Oh
cool, he'll be the main character--what do you MEAN he dies????" But
Brion's situation was rather different than Kelson's, as he got the
woman he wanted on the first try. (At least so far as we know.) But
then, Brion had to live with Jehana for years when SHE was at her most
difficult. Ah... so maybe THAT'S where Kelson got his adolescent
tendencies, from Mummy!.... <EG>
> And in response to jerry's proposition about seeing more about Wencit,
> that would be fascinating as well. Baddies generally have such
> interesting histories! Childhood trauma, lost love that turned them
> bitter forever, etc., etc. Could be fun!
Oh, I'm sure it will be. =o)
Melissa
Melissa
Indeed! You've been reading my mind again, Julianne. (of course,
that I've posted my opinions of both Cinhil and Kelson before may have
something to do with it!)
;-)
--
Wes Struebing
I pledge allegiance to the Constitution of the United States of America,
and to the republic which it established, one nation from many peoples,
promising liberty and justice for all.
Oh, lordy, yes, indeed! Had I been involved in that little caper, none of
the succeeding stories would have come about, because I would have found in
necessary to murder Cinhil myself!!!
Shoot. You all beat me to a response. Yes, my answer was going to be that
there would be no Kelson as a result of what I would have done to Cinhil.
It's really only in KKB that he Kelson drove me crazy. I thought he was
alright in the preceding books. I could forgive his behavior at times
because he was only 14 or 17 depending on the book. He really is a nice guy.
Just probably needs some Prozac to balance him out a little :-)
Irene
Completely agreed. I thought Kelson was fine all throughout the preceding
stories, but that incessant whining in KKB just got on my nerves...
Especially since he had handled so much so well in his previous life, when
he was presumably less mature, and it seemed very suddenly, he regressed to
the point I would have expected when he was 14 or so. I suppose one could
make a case for this being the straw the broke the camel's back or some such
platitude, but it just annoyed the daylights out of me.
Now, Cinhil, otoh, I *never* liked. He started out whiny and got worse....
Mary Alice Kropp wrote:
>
>Now, Cinhil, otoh, I *never* liked. He started out whiny and got worse....
>
>
>
Yes, there were times when you had to ask: just HOW bad WERE the Festils?
[Oh, and the Sea-legs comment about Kelson was a reference to his love
of traveling by ship <g>].
I seem to recall that one of the Festillic kings whined on about not
getting to stay in the monastary also? Does make you wonder!
Imladris
Melissa
And as for Rhysem -- how stupid can he be? Yes, I know he redeemed
himself in the end, dying heroically (more or less), but if he'd paid
attention to what Javan was telling him, there wouldn't have been a need
for Rhys Michael to die heroically or otherwise... Him, I frequently
want to whap hard where it'll do the most good...
**********
blessed be, Julianne
Melissa
Cinhil was a whiny jerk, but you know what? If he had risen the
occasion, said "Yes, I am a Haldane, and I will rule with nobility and
wisdom" I would have put the book down and never picked it up again.
Here was a guy who was raised as an ordinary person, with no inkling
that he was royal, he went into religious orders at a young age, led a
secluded life which he loved, and was forcibly removed in a pretty
shocking way, forced to renounce his celibacy and pick up a crown that
he didn't know was his to begin with. I might have been a bit whiny,
too.
And Rhys Michael is a very typical youngest child. He was the spare to
the spare heir. He was spoiled a bit and allowed to be self centered.
He behaved in character.
One of the things I love about the Camber era books is that the
characters are deeply flawed, even Camber himself, in a way that they
are not flawed in Kelson's era. That makes them more believable, and
more enjoyable to read. (That's not to say I don't love the Kelson
books, because I do, but I'm more inclined to re-read the Camber books)
Marion
I tend to agree with your assessment of Cinhil. He was a pompous
whiny person but when he finally accepted that he was going to be king
he settled down and became king, even if he probably never liked being
king. Didn't necessarily make all good choices but who does?
I do think somewhen he was told that he was a Haldane. Possibly when
his father died. I could see his grandfather taking him aside and
telling him. He had just put it to the back reaches of his mind when
he developed his calling to the church. When Joram and Rhys hit him
with it he reacted as one who knew but was in denial.
Rhys Michael- in CH he seemed to be the more normal kid of the Princes.
In KJY, yeah strangling him would have been a good thing. In TBP he
has had several years to ponder the errors of his ways and for the most
part redeems himself.
jerry
Melissa
Arilan has his vows to God and the Church, his fealty to the Crown, and
also to the Council, the last two groups seemingly at odds with each
other regularly. I agree that Arilan needs to let up on Duncan and
Alaric a little bit -- they have to make their own decisions as well,
and live with the consequences.
Regarding Alaric -- we know he loses his parents at a young age. He was
given to the Haldane service at birth. He never knew any life other
than being under the protection of the King, and to be the protector of
the Prince, first Brion, then Kelson. He is also the third most
powerful in rank in the kingdom. So to be all these things, you have to
be confident, perhaps to the point of arrogance, so that people will
listen to you -- especially at 14 or 15, after the battle with the
Marluk and the first ritual magic you have done alone is also
successful. (Which no one can know about which to Alaric was a very
great personal achievement).
My opinions. That and a buck fifty will get you a cup of coffee.
I think Alaric projects a public face of toughness and
self-confidence, but he also chooses a hard road in being an openly
known Deryni when he's still a very young man. And he has to live with
those consequences, both forseen and unforseen all his life. This is
only possible for him because he IS the king's close friend, and Brion
owes him a huge debt for helping to defeat the Marluk in addition to
that. But Morgan also had a very small circle of loyal friends and a
very LARGE circle of vehement detractors in bothe the church and the
court. In that atmosphere, he HAS to be tough, to discourage any casual
threats against him on a day to day basis. But I also think it means
he had a very lonely life, a lot of the time. Granted, Alaric is a bit
of an adrenaline junkie, but that kind of life would have to get to
him, now and then. And because he values the few true friends he has,
he is extremely loyal to them. I think one reason that Alaric resents
Arilan is that, until Arilan outed himself to Morgan and Duncan, he
pretty much allowed them to do as they thought best. After surviving
to the age of 29 operating on his own judgement, Alaric would hardly
take it kindly that Arilan is trying to tell him what to do and how to
use his own powers, when he has demonstrated enough judgement to
survive in a Deryni hostile land. But Morgan, who has lived openly as
a Deryni throughout his adulthood has probably done more to change
people's attitudes about Deryni than Arilan has. True, for Arilan to
be openly Deryni would have been suicide within the church when he was
first ordained, and during most of Brion's reign. But he STILL hasn't
come clean to the general Gwynedd Synod and said "Guess what? I'm a
Deryni Bishop, too. Deal with it." Since Duncan has been guardedly
accepted by both Bradene and the Synod, when is Denis going to pluck up
his nerve to dare to come out of the tabernacle, so to speak?
Melissa
I haven't read the Swords of Marluk (?). What is this? Where can I read it?
Irene
"Shiral" <shir...@hotmail.com> wrote in message
news:1139074137....@o13g2000cwo.googlegroups.com...
Melissa
"Shiral" <shir...@hotmail.com> wrote in message
news:1139092865.6...@g14g2000cwa.googlegroups.com...
> Has KK said if she will ever write anymore
> books about Kelson's reign?
I believe that KK said that she was going to give Kelson and Araxie a
little time alone before she gets back to them. Of course, then
there're her other books that she has to work on!
> I want to know
> what happens with Duncan and Alaric and all
> these characters after KKB.
What you said!
Kathleen
RainbowDragon
He might also want to stay hidden because to expose a second "secret"
Deryni in the priesthood might precipitate that backlash.
And, he's done quite a bit to help the cause of the Deryni in secret -
he was able to help Cardiel realize that Deryni weren't such a bad
thing, and I have to think that other bishops coming around to the
Deryni cause were influenced (non-magically) by Arilan.
I'm going to be very curious to see the relationship between Arilan and
Brion. I wonder how much influence Denis had on Brion's opinion of the
Deryni.
Plus - it's not like Alaric had any choice at being a known Deryni -
his mother was, after all. There was no hiding it. But Denis's family
was not known Deryni, and he's not the only one in that family - if he
were to announce he was Deryni, it would affect his brother's children.
(I think his brother is dead at this point.) Anyone who knows anything
about the backlash after the Haldane restoration can't be in any hurry
to expose his family to that risk.
Marion
jerry
There's a comment in the book about Arilan coming out as a Deryni. It was a
statement about how now they knew the people knew they had 2 Deryni Bishops
and things were changing. By the time KKB takes place it is not a crime to
be Deryni or a Deryni cleric and even Duncan makes a show of it during the
celebration at the new Camber Basilica.
Irene
Hmmm, methinks Arilan has got the insufferable title all to his self.
I don't think Dennis has faith in anyone's judgment other than his
own,,,,Joram on the other hand....That's what a good priest is all about :-)
"lenni" <kathleen...@homenode.us> wrote in message
news:1139112765.0...@g14g2000cwa.googlegroups.com...
Well, to his defense, I think he is a victim (if you will) of two
things - the earlier (and in some ways still extant) prejudice against
Deryni, and the upbringing in the Church. The two combined would make
someone, stiff-necked and guarded, not to mention looking askance at
those who *might* not feel quite the same way.
That said, insufferable is a good label!
8-)
--
Wes Struebing
I pledge allegiance to the Constitution of the United States of America,
and to the republic which it established, one nation from many peoples,
promising liberty and justice for all.
Jake wrote:
> Yeah, I'd kind of like to know a little more about what happens to those
> characters, but first, I want to know about 948 already. It's been driving
> me crazy ever since I got my original Codex.
I both do and do not want to see what happens in 948. Everybody
dies.... I heard a rumor that they all die helping hte Haldane king
who also dies... I also heard something about a plague that year and
with no Healers because the Regents were idiots....
It's gonna be one very depressing book. But I would still like to know
what goes on. That's it: I'm schizophrennic and so am I!
*************
blessed be, Julianne
Melissa
Imladris
Imladris wrote:
> Me three..., but would also like to someday read the story of the late
> 7th century with Oriel and Jodotha....
Oh, yes, Imladris! A definite "me, too" there!
*************
blessed be, Julianne
"Julianne Toomey-Kautz" <Julia...@Kautzlaw.com> wrote in message
news:ROidnSq1zo2...@rcn.net...
Seems it would have to be several books just to cover everyone who
dies...
(having mixed feelings about reading about that period. I'm not sure
how depressed I want to be...)
tell the story of 948 in the context of a later book (like CM III)
where there is a memorial to it or maybe they find a scroll telling the
true story (like finding the Orin papers)
Could it really be more depressing than the end of Camber the Heretic,
or of King Javan's Year? I don't think it could be, in part because
except for Joram, I'm not sure I have an emotional attachment to the
other characters the way I did for Camber, Rhys, Evaine or Javan. I
remember crying when I first read of Rhys's death. And that scene in
the castle yard, just before Evaine gave birth, was pretty devastating.
But I don't think they'll find the true story of 948 until after King
Kelson's Bride (chronologically, I mean) because there's no hint of it
in any of the Kelson books. I keep hoping that someone in Kelson's time
will discover the history that one of the bishops was writing in KJY.
Marion