On 10/20/2012 11:00 PM, John Canal wrote:
> In article <5083594...@mcadams.posc.mu.edu>, Anthony Marsh says...You stated falsely that the brain matter exploded out of the front of
>> On 10/20/2012 9:09 PM, John Canal wrote:
>>>> First of all, your illustration does not show us where the explosion
>>> You're an expert at image analysis (e.g. ducking, prtrusions, etc.) so you
>> Maybe you've never seen the Zapruder film so you never saw the jets of
> Did I say that no brain matter exploded out the top of his head? No, but
the head. But there is no hole there for it to escape.
>>>> Also, I don't know how we can do anything meaningful without a 3D model
>>>> to work with.
>>> Oh, so you can't do a 2D drawing (from above the brain) showing where your
>> You tried and you failed.
> That's your opinion.
>>> If a bullet caused your protrusion it sure looks to me like the rear left
>> So you think when skull bones are fractured they damage the brain
> I think that when someone claims a bullet caused a protrusion that is
>>>> But the biggest problem is that I don't know the path of that bullet. If
>>> Fine then draw two or three options in different colors...come on Mr.
>> Where are your divergent paths for the multiple fragments? They didn't
>>>> Since I have answered a number of your questions,
>>> No you did not......and until you draw those 2D possible paths (one color
>> We await YOUR revised drawing.
>>> John Canal
>>>> perhaps you will
>>>> Or do you agree with McAdams that this is all a figment of my imagination?
>>>> Robert Harris
>>>> John Canal wrote:
>>>>>> Decide for yourselves folks.
>>>>>> This is not a Rorschach test or an optical illusion. The protrusion is
>>>>>> This image explains the nature of the damage and the only way it could
>>>>> Robert, I have a request if you have time.
>>>>> Please refer to the copy of the superior brain drawing (see the link
>>>>> Now, I've drawn on the image the path that I think the major pieces (those
>>>>> Please note that it is readily apparent from the damage that brain tissue
>>>>> Robert, since you're such an adept image analyzer do me a favor and draw
You must Sign in before you can post messages.
To post a message you must first join this group.
Please update your nickname on the subscription settings page before posting.
You do not have the permission required to post.