Injustices of NWFP Public Service Commission in PMS Exam for top Bureacracy
Mard-e-Kohistan
Subject: Injustices/blunders done in the awarding of Interview Marks
in Provincial Management
Service Exam NWFP completed in December 2009.
I appeared in the first NWFP Public Service Commission Provincial
Management Service Competitive exam of NWFP held in December 2008
under Roll No 15424 and secured 704 Marks out of 1200 with 58.6
percentages thus qualified this exam with distinction as only few
candidates in the whole province have been able to cross 700 Marks or
above score.
This exam was being taken on exact pattern of CSS competitive exam
with similar syllabus however its interview or psychological tests
held in October 2009 were not conducted on CSS pattern but rather some
amateur method was followed which has already been created some
dissatisfactory feeling among the experienced candidates like me.
Some of the points are highlighted below
1. Only two people conducted this interview including Chairman and a
Deputy Secretary
2. Two to three irrelevant questions were asked and this was suggested
to me not to join this service as I would be paid low.
3. The Chairman Sahib was smoking during the interview and nothing
concrete was inquired from me during my interview.
4. Some of the candidates were given 200 marks out of 300 despite that
their written marks were 600 only which is the qualifying figure.
5. Many of the candidates with whom the interviewing panel had got
some acquaintance were given high colours in interview results despite
that their written marks were lesser than me.
6. I have got only 120(40%) Marks in my interview despite that I was
in top ten positions in the written portion of the exam by securing 704
(58.66%) Marks.
7. Due to this discriminations I am now at 58th position on merit
which is not acceptable to me as during the history of my exams in
NWFP Public Service Commission I have got 60% marks during my
interview for the same posts in 2005.
8. There are some signs that some unfair means have been used during
this PMS exam interview and people have been given the chance to reach
top positions for getting good posts and seniority for further
promotions which is injustice with people like me who has started
appearing in these exams since 2000 and I have also served as
Assistant Superintendent Jail by getting 2nd position in the exam held
under NWFP Public Service Commission in the year 2000.
9. Many of the candidates were called for interview on the orders of
Honorable High Court of Peshawar the detail is available in the Press
Release below which also shows irregularities in the conduction of
this exam as candidates who were once declared failed were selected
after the conclusion of interview.
10. I have also got throughout first position during my academic
career and have got distinctions in different extra curricular
activities including sports with strong background of general
knowledge as well.
11. To sum up I am more competent than many of the candidates who
stood senior to me in the commission seniority list on merit who were
awarded high marks during the interview despite that they got low
marks in their written portion while I was pushed backward by awarding
low marks in the unsystematic interview process despite that I came
with shining colours during the written portion of the examination
which shows injustice, unfair play and illegal conduct on the part
of the commission highest officers thus paving the way of injustices
and unfair play in the society as well.
12. Much can be said about the character of the chairman of NWFP
Public Service Commission which is popular among all and sundry and is
indeed questionable however poor candidates like me can not do
anything against such influential government officers; we can only
call for our lord sitting above the world or can knock the doors of
your good office being the only light of hope in Pakistani society.
13. It is meekly requested in your honour to take sue motive action in
this context so that some reasonable marks should be awarded to me in
the interview keeping in mind my long struggle, past experience and
results, my academic career and achievements and the facts on ground
by applying some systematic way of the interview and not just using
the so called discretionary powers.
14. The notification of NWFP Public Service Commission is attached for
ready reference
Obediently Yours
Baidullah Shah
House No CB-57 Model Colony New Gadwal Post Office 26 Area Wah Cantt.
Tel Off: 0512288858 Islamabad
Tel Res: 0514533912 Wah Cantt:
Cell: 03145036989
PRESS RELEASE
It is notified for general information that in consequence to this
Commission advertisement No. 02/2008 for 195 Posts of Provincial
Management Service (PMS) Officer (B-17) (including posts reserved for
females, disables and Earthquake affectees), the Commission received
18,160 Applications. All eligible Candidates were admitted for
Competitive examinations. Of these 4138 Candidates appeared in the
examination out of which 180 Candidates qualified.
The qualified candidates were called for viva voce test
(including Seventy Four (74) Petitioners who have been granted relief
by Peshawar High Court-Peshawar/ Abbottabad Bench) scheduled w.e.f
28-09-2009 to 21-10-2009 and on 24-10-2009, 18-11-2009, 21-11-2009,
25-11-2009, 10-12-2009 and 12-12-2009 . After the conclusion of
interviews, the Commission has finally recommended the following
candidates for appointment in accordance with the prescribed Zonal
Allocation Formula.
one seventy-eight (178) posts of pms Officer
Successful candidates are as under:-
S.No. Name with Father Name Domicile/Zone
1. Muhammad Irfanullah S/O Muhammad Alam Khan S.W Agy/1
2. Muhammad Fayyaz Khan S/O Wali Khan Charsadda/2
3. Muhammad Khalid Zaman S/O Shams-uz-Zaman Mardan/2
4. Mohammad Rafiq Khan Mohmand S/O Mohammad Aslam Khan Mohmand Moh
Agy/1
5. Khalid Khan S/O Wazir Muhammad Moh Agy/1
6. Muhammad Naeem Khan S/O Abdul Aziz Bajour Agy/1
7. Muhammad Tahir S/O Rehman Said Moh Agy/1
8. Fahad Wazir S/O Muhammad Javed Wazir F.R Bannu/1
9. Mohib-ur-Rehman S/O Habib-ur-Rehman Peshawar/2
10. Muhammad Hayat S/O Sanab Gul Moh Agy/1
11. Zeeshan Abdullah S/O Abdullah Khan S.W Agy/1
12. Noor Alam Khan S/O Koid Aman S.W Agy/1
13. Minhas-ud-Din S/O Nasim Ahmad Chitral/3
14. Noor-ul-Amin S/O Zar Moeen D.I Khan/4
15. Shah Saud S/O Khitab Gul Peshawar/2
16. Zahoor Baber S/O Malik Muhammad Daud Afridi Khy Agy/1
17. Muhammad Sher S/O Ghulam Nabi Buner/3
18. Irfan Ullah Khan S/O Dilawar Khan F.R Bannu/1
19. Muhammad Riaz Khan S/O Musa Khan N.W Agy/1
20. Arshad Ali S/O Shah Jehan D.I Khan/4
21. Abdul Nasir Khan S/O Abdur Qadir Khan Moh Agy/1
22. Muhammad Shakeel S/O Amir Zada Peshawar/2
23. Abdullah S/O Waliullah Swabi/2
24. Muhammad Ilyas S/O Muhammad Shah Nowshera/2
25. Muhammad Nawaz S/O Sahib Gul F.R Bannu/1
26. Hafiz Ataul Munim S/O Abdur Rashid F.R Bannu/1
27. Javid Ali S/O Hameed-ul-Hassan Orakzai Agy/1
28. Asif Ali S/O Salar Khan Swabi/2
29. Abdul Haseeb S/O Inayat Ullah Peshawar/2
30. Yasir Ali Khan S/O Zafar Ali Khan Nowshera/2
31. Zia-ur-Rehman S/O Abdur Rahman Dir(L)/3
32. Basharat Ahmad S/O Zulfiqar Sher Chitral/3
33. Gul Akbar Khan S/O Noor Faraz Khan Mardan/2
34. Wajid Ali Khan S/O Imdad Khan Peshawar/2
35. Altaf Hussain S/O Sher Alam Dir (L)/3
36. Hamid-ur-Rehman S/O Usman Gul Kohat/4
37. Imran Khan S/O Faramosh Khan Swat/3
38. Fiaz Alam S/O Mehr Amin Karak/4
39. Wasil Khan S/O Zahir Khan Karak/4
40. Syed Roman Ali Shan S/O Muhammad Zafar Ali Shah Bannu/4
41. Hazrat Ali S/O Muhammad Ali Nowshera/2
42. Naik Muhammad S/O Noor Rehman Mardan/2
43. Dil Nawaz Khan S/O Muhammad Ismail Khan F.R Bannu/1
44. Habib Ullah Khan S/O Sabz Ali F.R Bannu/1
45. Muhammad Ishaq S/O Muhammad Jamil MKD Agy/3
46. Abdul Haleem Khan S/O Abdur Rauf Khan N.W Agy/1
47. Tariq Mehmood S/O Muhammad Sadiq Haripur/5
48. Khalid Iqbal S/O Hayat Khan Karak/4
49. Rashid Khan S/O Sher Din Nowshera/2
50. Syed Saif-ul-Islam Shah S/O Syed Abdul Latif Shah Mansehra/5
51. Shah Hussain S/O Gul Shed Mardan/2
52. Mansoor Alam S/O Muhammad Baseer Khan F.R Bannu/1
53. Baidullah Shah S/O Iran Bad Shah Kohat/4
54. Jehangir Azam Wazir S/O Sher Azam Wazir S.W Agy/1
55. Muhammad Naeem Khan S/O Muhammad Yousaf Khan Mardan/2
56. Muhammad Tayyab Abdullah S/O Abdullah Haripur/5
57. Nasar Ali S/O Inayat Ullah Moh Agy/1
58. Irfanullah S/O Inayatullah S.W Agy/1
59. Hameed Ullah S/O Amtali Khan Karak/4
60. Baseer Ali Rehman Khan S/O Abdul Rehman Mano Khan Peshawar/2
61. Muhammad Zahid S/O Muhammad Ishaq Peshawar/2
62. Khaliq Dad Khan S/O Silli Mar Jan F.R Bannu/1
63. Muhammad Naveed Akbar S/O Ali Akbar Abbottabad/5
64. Khan Muhammad S/O Abdul Jalil Moh Agy/1
65. Muhammad Tariq S/O Muhammad Saleem Peshawar/2
66. Muhammad Iqbal Khan S/O Muhammad Rehman F.R Bannu/1
67. Muhammad Iqbal S/O Wali Jan Bajour Agy/1
68. Muhammad Zaher-ur-Din Baber S/O Murad Ali Khan Swabi/2
69. Mir Khawas Khan S/O Akram Khan N.W Agy/1
70. Muhammad Anwar Khan S/O Ajmal Khan F.R D.I Khan/1
71. Muhammad Ejaz Khan S/O Muhammad Pervez Mardan/2
72. Muhammad Farooq S/O Said Ahmad Shah F.R Peshawar/1
73. Muhammad Shoaib S/O Zain-ul-Abidin Charsadda/2
74. Muhammad Fawad S/O Khalil-ur-Rehman MKD Agy/3
75. Zia-ur-Rehman S/O Muhammad Iqbal Khan Lakki Marwat/4
76. Abdul Hadi S/O Abdul Haleem Chitral/3
77. Muhammad Sheeraz S/O Raees Khan Swabi/2
78. Muhammad Ali Khan S/O Qaim Khan Haripur/5
79. Muhammad Ishaq S/O Guldar Ali F.R Bannu/1
80. Said Nawab S/O Ghazi Khan Swat/3
81. Javed Iqbal S/O Kaboot Khan Swabi/3 UDA
82. Muhammad Zahid S/O Muhammad Younas Swabi/2
83. Hamid Ali S/O Noor Hanif Shah Mardan/2
84. Rizwan Ullah Khan S/O Aziz Ullah Khan D.I Khan/4
85. Muhammad Abdullah Shah S/O Muhammad Yaqoob Shah S.W Agy/1
86. Muhammad Tufail S/O Mir Shah Nawaz Karak/4
87. Malik Manzoor Ahmad S/O Malik Dost Muhammad Charsadda/2
88. Shahid Khan S/O Sadbar Khan Moh Agy/1
89. Ahmed Kamal S/O Shams-ul-Islam Nowshera/2
90. Muhammad Saleh S/O Muhammad Zakir Khan Chitral/3
91. Muhammad Ayaz Khan S/O Zurab Gul Moh Agy/1
92. Hakmat Ullah S/O Zaid Ullah Khan F.R Bannu/1
93. Shahid Ali S/O Sultan-e-Room Swat/3
94. Sadaqat Ullah S/O Sher Muhammad D.I Khan/4
95. Mahmood Ahmad S/O Shah Nawaz Khan Charsadda/2
96. Samiullah Khan S/O Bismillah Jan F.R Bannu/1
97. Kamran Khan S/O Mir Rehman Shaheen Charsadda/2
98. Amanat Khan S/O Jamshid Khan Moh Agy/1
99. Noor Wali Khan S/O Hakim Jan F.R Bannu/1
100. Muhammad Abbas Khan S/O Muhammad Sabir Abbottabad/5
101. Ashfaq Ahmad S/O Khan Badshah MKD Agy/3
102. Khurshid Alam S/O Hashim Khan Karak/4
103. Muhammad Yasir Hassan S/O Hafiz Mehmood-ul-Hassan Haripur/5
104. Mian Abdul Qadir Shah S/O Mian Sharafat Shah Peshawar/2
105. Abdul Kabir S/O Akram Jan Khy Agy/1
106. Noor-ul-Amin S/O Gul Dad Khan Bannu/4
107. Muhammad Hayat Shah S/O Muhammad Ghazi Shah Chitral/3
108. Musarrat Zaman S/O Sher Akbar Charsadda/2
109. Nawab Khan S/O Khan Said Peshawar/2
110. Naeem Ullah Khan S/O Rahim Khan Bannu/4
111. Manzoor Ahmad Afridi S/O Muhammad Ilyas Afridi Khy Agy/1
112. Ansar Mehmood S/O Munsif Gul Haripur/5
113. Sami-ur-Rehman S/O Khan Raziq Charsadda/2
114. Muhammad Saleem S/O Behram Khan Mansehra/5
115. Jamal-ud-Din S/O Fazal Muhammad MKD/3
116. Muhammad Taufique S/O Gulab Khan Haripur/5
117. Shah Nawaz Naveed S/O Jan Muhammad Peshawar/2
118. Kashif Iqbal Jilani S/O Ghulam Jilani Asif Peshawar/2
119. Touseef Khalid S/O Khalid Mahmood Peshawar/2
120. Maqbool Hussain S/O Tajamal Hussain Peshawar/2
121. Syed Mazhar Ali Shah S/O Syed Abdul Jalal Chitral/3
122. Jamshed Khan S/O Mir Kaman Khan Swat/3
123. Mujeeb-ur-Rehman S/O Nazir-ur-Rehman Nowshera/2
124. Amjad Mairaj S/O Imraj Gul Kohat/4
125. Tariq Jamal S/O Gul Jamal Dir (L)/3
126. Ashfaq Khan S/O Amin-ul-Haq Dir (L)/3
127. Pir Muhammad Khan S/O Noor Muhammad Dir (L)/3
128. Bashir Ahmad S/O Daulat Khan Buner/3
129. Riaz Muhammad S/O Noor Muhammad S.W Agy/1
130. Kamran Khattak S/O Hashmat Ullah Kohat/4
131. Muhammad Abid S/O Muhammad Iqbal Abbottabad/5
132. Sher Alam Khan S/O Sher Afzal Khan Swat/3
133. Fayaz Muhammad S/O Nazar Muhammad Swabi/2
134. Muhammad Nadeem Akhtar S/O Muhammad Ilyas Abbottabad/5
135. Abdul Akram S/O Muhammad Nadir Shah Chitral/3
136. Imran Mashal S/O Mashal Khan Kohat/4
137. Pir Muhammad S/O Muhammad Khan S.W Agy/1
138. Muhammad Arif Khan S/O Muhammad Irshad Asif Nowshera/2
139. Sardar Bahadar S/O Naimat Ullah Khan Bannu/4
140. Asif Ali S/O Muhammad Din Charsadda/2
141. Tanwir Khan S/O Shaista Khel Karak/4
142. Muhammad Yousaf Khan S/O Haj Khan Kohat/4
143. Habib Khan S/O Yar Afzal Khy Agy/1
144. Ikhlaq Ahmed S/O Muhammad Rasool Kohat/4
145. Asad Sarwar S/O Sarwar Sultan Mansehra/3 (U/T)
146. Imran Zia S/O Zia-ud-Din Abbottabad/5
147. Tariq Mehmood S/O Khush Muhammad Khan Chitral/3
148. Anwar Zeb S/O Alam Zeb Charsadda/2
149. Izaz Ullah S/O Hidayat Ullah Charsadda/2
150. Zia-ur-Rehman S/O Muqarrab Khan Karak/4
151. Muhammad Arif Khan S/O Muhammad Hamayun Shangla/3
152. Tanveer Ahmed S/O Kala Khan Mansehra/5
153. Amir Rehman Mohmand S/O Abdul Ghafoor Moh Agy/1
154. Jamshid Khan S/O Lal Muhammad Moh Agy/1
155. Zakir Hussain S/O Muhammad Humayun Mansehra/5
156. Jan Muhammad S/O Haji Sher Jan Moh Agy/1
157. Muhammad Ayaz Khan S/O Redool Khan Mardan/2
158. Muhammad Asif S/O Zakir Hussain Abbottabad/5
159. Muhammad Asif S/O Saeed-ur-Rehman Battagram/3
160. Syed Habib ul Hassan Gillani S/O Syed Riaz Hussain Shah
Mansehra/5
161. Qasim Ali Khan S/O Abdur Rasheed Khan Abbottabad/5
162. Mushtaq Hussain S/O Abdul Hanan Mansehra/5
163. Amir Hassan Khan S/O Muhammad Hussain Shangla/3
164. Muhammad Arshid S/O Abdur Rashid Abbasi Abbottabad/5
165. Muhammad Irshad S/O Sikander Khan Abbottabad/5
166. Yasir Imran S/O Shah Imran Mansehra/5
167. Abbas Ali Bukhary S/O Syed Chand Farid Shah Mansehra/5
168. Khadija Hayat D/O Hayat Ullah Charsadda/2
169. Naghmana D/O Nasrullah Khan Mardan/2
170. Naj-Mus-Sahar S/O Aziz-ur-Rehman Peshawar/2
171. Shama Niamat D/O Niamat Khan Swat/3
172. Irum Naz D/O Mukhtiar Khan Mardan/2
173. Aamna Ameen D/O Sahib Zada Muhammad Ameen Peshawar/2
174. Aasma Arif D/O Muhammad Arif Khan Mardan/2
175. Bibi Fatima D/O Gul Muhammad Lakki Marwat/4
176. Tabassum D/O Mir Muhammad Mardan/2
177. Faryal Kazim D/O Muhammad Kazim Kurram Agy/1
178. Zuhra Nigar D/O Karam Ali Bannu/4