Really, I think your dismissal of this work is unfair. If there were
contamination in the form of plasmids contributed from other bacteria,
there would be plasmids in the citrate-using strain. There isn't.
They can show that the new bacteria is the ancestor of the original
strain. "Activation of cryptic genes" in this context is more similar
to what I would describe as cooptation, which in itself is no small
feat. That is, the genes for some existing protein or series of
proteins were gradually altered in such a way that they were put to
work at a second task to what they normally do, namely digesting
citrate. But what if the changes were in non-coding regions of DNA,
or pseudogenes? Would that now qualify as OEEI? I'm concerned that
what your asking for is a demonstration of ex nihilo creation of a
gene, genetic material and all. Evolution requires some heritable
material to act upon, either from gene duplication, abiogenic methods,
or other means; nothing poofs into existence.
I appreciate the question you're trying to ask, but ultimately isn't
the fact that we're here, living with millions of other species
filling every conceivable niche, demonstrate that evolution can
innovate? If the answer is "no, genetic material could have been
delivered from space", then lets just zoom out our frame of reference
from the earth to the solar system, or the universe.
--
Mike Markey
http://www.geocities.com/jfsebastion/